返回顶部
News

Analysis for Video Conference and Live-broadcasting Teaching Platform

The Ministry of Education of the PRC has issued a series of policies to support continuing learning at home since breakdown of COVID-19 disease in 2020. As a result, over 294 million teachers and students throughout the country have deployed a super-large scale of online education practice where various tools such as live-broadcasting, VOD, recorded broadcast and class management have been used.

According to Online Teaching Status and Excellent Examples issued by CIQA in March 2020, most of colleges and universities have used diversified online teaching modes of which one to two online teaching platforms and other auxiliary online teaching tools are selected. The main online teaching platforms or tools include Chaoxing, Tencent Meeting, DingTalk, Zhihuishu, ZOOM, Rain Classroom, China’s University MOOC, School Platform, XuetangX, Cloud Classroom, WeChat. 

Figure 1 Application and distribution of various online teaching platforms or tools

The Report of Interactive Research over Online Education in the Middle and Primary School During COVID-19 Disease issued by New Media Communication Research Center of BNU and Guangming Daily Education Research Center has indicated that all interviewees 2377 primary and middle school teachers throughout the country have used 39 online education products as below. These products with over 10% utilization rate are sorted as social software such as WeChat and QQ; DingTalk; National Primary and Middle School Network Platform; Zuoyebang; Tencent Classroom from high to low.

Figure 2 Application and distribution of online education products in Report of Interactive Research over Online Education in the Middle and Primary School During COVID-19 Disease

 

I. Main functions and technical features of online education platform

The main platforms that have applied online teaching include remote office/cloud video conference, social platform, teaching interaction platform, online classroom platform, network learning space/TV, and learning administration system.

Figure 3 Types of main online teaching platforms

The functions of each online teaching platform have been compared as shown in Figure 4.

Figure 4 Functional comparison of main online teaching platforms

The analysis for main functions of online teaching platform has been shown in Figure 5. Tencent Classroom and Rain Classroom are specially designed and developed to support online classroom platform and learning administration system, of which functions and features focus on classroom resources, student analysis and classroom interaction and satisfy with demands of the education sector. However, live-broadcasting teaching focuses on one-way broadcasting teaching with simple form of interaction. Zoom, DingTalk and QQ Group can better support learning demands in online teaching instead of supporting learning as video conference tools. Their main functions and features focus on two-way live-broadcasting, but other platform tools are also required for supporting other functions. Although platform administration and interaction are advantageous, curriculum resources, student analysis and statistics are not enough.

Figure 5 Analysis for main functions of online teaching platform

The functional comparison and analysis for common platforms such as Tencent Classroom, QQ, DingTalk and Zoom have been shown in Figure 6.

Figure 6 Functional comparison and analysis for cloud video conference and live-broadcasting platform

II. Current online teaching problems and analysis of causes for platform breakdown

According to Online Teaching Status and Excellent Examples issued by CIQA in March 2020, online teaching has shown many problems and shortcomings in:

  1. Online teaching platform system: Inadequate volume of the online teaching platform cannot meet users’ demands during the peak period. Scattered teaching platform results in inconvenient learning for students. Enough teaching functions have not been developed in curriculum platform.
  2. Teaching resources and curriculum content: The online curriculum resources have low satisfaction degree and imbalanced distribution and lack review mechanism. The attribute of curriculum has not highly matched with the form of teaching.
  3. Teacher’s teaching design, skill obtaining and interaction with students: The teacher’s online teaching design and skill obtaining have not achieved optimal effects; online interaction is limited, as a result, teachers cannot determine students’ status in class.
  4. Self-learning, online management, homework & exercise and learning effects: Online self-learning and management cannot be controlled better; online teaching leaves more homework for students compared to traditional teaching; some students have difficulties in online learning and in showing their unique advantages.

The Report of Interactive Research over Online Education in the Middle and Primary School During COVID-19 Disease issued by New Media Communication Research Center of BNU and Guangming Daily Education Research Center has indicated that inadequate interaction is the top one problem in online education from feedback of teachers. Because of technical defects such as inadequate interaction between teachers and students and complex operation in online learning environment, students are usually lonely and helpless, which has affected their learning. Therefore, current online education shall be further improved in interaction function.   

Figure 7 Feedback of current problems in online education from teachers in middle and primary school

 

The disconnection and breakdown of online learning platform are frequent at the beginning of online learning mainly because:

  1. Students of different grades connect the Internet at the same time, resulting in typical and obvious moment peak value and overload flow. Because video application is greatly sensitive to time delay, jitter and data loss, users may have bad experience.
  2. Many colleges and universities have built online teaching system and platforms of which utilization rate is low and there is not large-scale online practice and enough system pressure tests.
  3. Because of being designed with complex and diversified functions, some systems can work normally in simple LAN environment instead of in large-scale concurrent access.

The Technical Survey and Research over Online Teaching Platform issued by Intelligent Learning Academy of National Engineering Laboratory for Cyberlearning and Intelligent Technology of BNU has indicated structure and form of several products for online learning applied by current educational institutions. However, causes of breakdown for various frameworks are different.

  1. The school’s platform is generally designed with “campus learning platform” + “cloud live-broadcasting service”. The system can avoid mass flow impact after large-scale application and practice in staggering peak. Otherwise, initial log-on cannot be successful. Besides, due to physical environment of the school, expansion cannot be realized in a short time. Therefore, redundant computing resources shall be reserved.
  2. The county and district level cloud education platform and online cloud platform of education information enterprises are usually expanded easily, but require synchronous implementation for access layer, gateway, application layer and resources.
  3. The Internet enterprises, including Baidu, Ali, Tencent and Huawei, have built their own learning platforms with unique background based on Zhongtai. Most of live-broadcasting classes have encountered time delay and lag at the beginning of online teaching because of peaking time of remote office. DingTalk and WeChat are main online tools for remote office, while live-broadcasting of Ali and Tencent cannot be expanded in a short time due to access of service operators.

According to Technical Survey and Research over Online Teaching Platform issued by Intelligent Learning Academy of National Engineering Laboratory for Cyberlearning and Intelligent Technology of BNU, the breakdown step of streaming media transmission for network broadcast is flow promotion at broadcaster terminal – content distribution in network – play by users.

III. How to guarantee service quality of online education platform

From the view of technology, implementing online teaching throughout the school requires various supports, including network, system, and cloud dispatching.

According to Technical Survey and Research over Online Teaching Platform issued by Intelligent Learning Academy of National Engineering Laboratory for Cyberlearning and Intelligent Technology of BNU, online teaching platform shall realize live broadcasting, interaction and low latency and not encounter lag, disconnection and downtime. At present, technical guarantee for online teaching platform has presented three features as below:

  1. Client: PC, mobile phone, Pad;
  2. Network communication: Over 1T and over 2M network communication are required for service provider and teachers & students respectively;
  3. Server: Mostly depending on cloud service platforms of the third party, for example, Baidu Cloud, AliCloud, Tencent Cloud, Huawei Cloud.

When online video communication is considered to use in education, some important features shall also be paid more attention to, including two-way video and audio, video network seminar, video grouping and meeting room, recording, send file and grouping message, calendar/ID identification integration, screen sharing, mobile startup, support integration, support development and hardware terminal integration, because they bring more flexible and valuable experience for teachers and students.

During the epidemic, various online teaching modes such as online open curriculum, online live-broadcasting teaching and VOD teaching have been widely used. As an online teaching mode approximate to offline class, online live-broadcasting teaching is featured with high interaction level and strong presence for teachers. However, low flow may result in bad network stability. Therefore, integrating multiple online teaching modes, building full-media learning ecology and combining online open curriculum with online live-broadcasting teaching will be future development directions.

Based on big data, AI and virtual reality, we can effectively implement student analysis and satisfy with interactive demands to create a better immersive environment and improve learning experience. Pushing learning resources in high-efficient and intelligent way can find users by resources to improve individualized learning for students.

release time:2020-06-10